Angela Scott
  • Home
  • About Me

Why Would An Author Deliberately Buy False Reviews? Why?  

8/7/2013

6 Comments

 
For every good reason there is to lie, there is a better reason to tell the truth. --Bo Bennett
Most readers before making the decision to buy a book look at what others are saying about it. More specifically, they peruse the reviews--the good and the bad. I, myself, tend to scan the 1 and 2 star reviews first. My reason: THEY TEND TO BE FAR MORE BELIEVABLE. They tell the truth. Now don't get me wrong, there are some seriously bizarre people out there who thrive on the negative. They're not pleased with anything in life, the poor souls, and it shows in their reviews. And of course, there are those carpet bombers who leave a 1 star review just to pull down a successful authors ratings (these can be bought too--shameful, huh?). What I'm talking about are the 1 and 2 star reviews with a great deal of meat behind them. I read those first. Why? Because more and more now days it's hard to trust a five star review. I'm not alone in this belief either. Check out this article when you get a moment. 

But Angela! Why would you say such a thing? You're an author! You know how hard it is to get reviews, any reviews for a book and five star reviews are AWESOME! Authors KILL for them! Okay, that's an exaggeration. Authors don't really "kill" for reviews...but they have been known to lie to get them.
Ever heard of best-selling UK crime author, RJ Ellory or another author Steven Leather? If you haven't, then click those links, but I'm quite certain you've heard of John Locke who bought 300 reviews from an online business that actually offered this as a service (the website GettingBookReviews.com shut down but you can read more HERE. Even though this one business is gone, there are dozen of others out there still). Steven Leather admitted to doing this very thing and actually said, "everyone does it".

No, Mr. Leather, not EVERYONE is doing it. I don't do it and I know MANY MANY wonderful authors who choose to go the honest route, however hard and long it may be. The problem is that there are still authors today (you'd think they'd learn by these bad apples above) who continue to beg, bribe, and even pay for a quick and positive review to boost their rankings. It's true. I've seen it. I'm absolutely shocked because I would've thought we'd moved past this. Apparently, we haven't.

My question for these authors is WHY? Why would you deliberately do this to yourself?

My guess is the following: Your book sucks rocks and you know it. You know it's not written well or the plot line is weak. Maybe you've had early feedback on the negative side and so in an effort to hide that from the public, you seek out in a desperate move to improve your ratings and camouflage the truth. Like placing daisies on top of a pile of poop.

Yes, it is hard and can take a lot of work to get the reviews that are needed to help give legitimacy and value to your book. I've been there--sending out email after email to book bloggers, hoping that maybe they'd be willing to give my book a try. But I wouldn't have it any other way. I'm building a reputation here. That matters more than anything to me. I'd rather have a handful of honest reviews, whatever stars they may be, than a hundred made up ones.

Eventually the honest reviews will reveal the work's true worth in the end and your reputation will be destroyed for trying to take a shortcut. These fake reviews will only result to more negative reviews as readers will ultimately feel as though they've been mislead (which they have). 

Here's the thing too: These sockpuppet reviews LOOK and READ fake. It really doesn't take a genius to figure out which ones are false and which ones are not (I'm not a genius--though I play one online--and I figured it out):


1) The reviews tend to be quite short. Maybe one or two sentences in length.
2) They usually say something like this: "I loved this book. It was a real good read. I would recommend it to everyone."
3) Usually, there are MANY of these one and two sentence type reviews back to back. Looks a little fishy.
4) What are the odds that THAT many people read your book and posted a review within a short period of days?
5) The reviewer has no profile picture. They have only reviewed one or two books and almost all of their reviews sound the same. True, there are people who set up an account to review a book and have no profile pic or very few reviews under their belt, so that's not always a tell-tell sign, but when there are MANY of these kind of profiles back to back reviewing the same book, I suggest you be a little suspicious.
6) Be skeptical of only positive reviews. Once again, don't get me wrong. There are wonderful books out there with 3 star and above ratings that deserve them. BUT, look at the comments themselves. Do they discuss the characters, the plot, the tension, ANYTHING about the book itself to prove they've even read it? Saying, "I loved this book. It was a good read. I would recommend it to everyone" says NOTHING.
7) On the flip side, be wary of only negative reviews. Once again, there's that whole carpet bombing thing that goes around. So sad.
8) Also, watch out for reviews that tend to sound like plot summaries or rephrasing of the book's description.

The best thing you can do, as a reader, is download a sample of the book before purchasing it. Read it and decide from there. It's terrible that the world is so deceptive and that some authors have chosen to stoop so low.

Authors who pay for fake reviews, in my opinion, are wanting to sell more books than they are wanting to write them. If selling is the big priority, then by all means creep down the dark alleyways of the internet and find the companies offering what you're looking for. They're out there. Just remember, what goes around comes around. Secrets have a way of finding the light. I heard a quote (though not sure by who, because I can't find it now) that fake reviews to an author is like handing plastic fruit to a chef. They're basically useless.

Authors, a word of advice for you: DON'T DO IT. Just don't. The small amount of success you may receive from being deceptive isn't worth it. It's not. Let your work speak for itself, because when you don't  it only ends up damaging readers' trust and that, in the end, hurts us all.
6 Comments
Laura Thomas link
8/8/2013 08:15:16 am

Impressive and entertaining post today Angela!

Had me laughing in a few places.

How can an author think buying ratings will help them. When people spend their pennies and find out the book is a dud, they'll be sure to leave their comments.

I have given many 3, 4, and 5 star reviews. I write my own synopsis and give my thoughts. It can take days to write a review sometimes. And I often reread a book so I can get the experience without taking notes.
I resent that reviews are written without bothering to read the book. How could that possibly be honest.
My review is a recommendation and I write it for readers.
On a lighter note - I did review Wanted: Dead or Undead and gave it a well deserved high rating! I have yet to read Survivor Roundup and now I see book three, Dead Plains, is coming out!

Reply
Elise Forier Edie link
8/10/2013 12:38:54 am

The sad thing is, now I just don't believe ANY 5 star reviews -- unless they are from a Goodreads reviewer I trust. I always read the one and two star reviews before I buy a book. "I just didn't like it" or "I like the action to move faster" tells me I actually might want to buy the book. "This book has spelling and grammatical errors and makes no sense" -- I know it's a stinker and I should save my money. THANK YOU TO THE ONE AND TWO STAR REVIEWERS! Your honesty is appreciated. And a huge raspberry to authors who buy good reviews! It just erases any kind of standards for the rest of us.

Reply
Susan Stuckey
8/23/2013 03:49:15 am

Excellent post although it is just touches the tip of the iceberg (by addressing only the bought with $ reviews)in my opinion. My experience is that it is more beneficial to ignore ALL reviews. If I cannot read a sample (other than the beginning) or download a sample, I won't buy the book.

Reply
Nicky link
8/23/2013 11:55:15 pm

I've said it before and I'll say it again: reviews have never influenced my decision to buy a book. I don't trust them and I never have. I'll read them after I've finished a book to see how many other people shared my opinion, but as far as boosting an author's sales? Not with me, sorry.

Reply
Jenny link
10/15/2013 12:11:43 am

A few months ago I was looking for a very specific type of book to take with me on vacation. The book in question fit all the criteria and it had over 400 reviews. Only a handful of them were negative, but I wish I'd paid more attention to those when I was debating whether to try the book. Of the 400+ reviews, only about 35 were 1-2 stars, but they spoke volumes compared to the 3,4 and 5 star reviews. The positive reviews were short, as you mentioned. Claiming the book was perfect and they couldn't wait for more from the author, but the book was far from perfect. It was riddled with spelling and grammar errors and the writing was very immature. I don't know for a fact that the author paid for his reviews, but I have my suspicions. It's sad that some are willing to pay for false reviews to lure in unsuspecting readers.

Reply
Brooke R. Busse link
4/9/2014 03:01:55 pm

I don't tend to read a lot of reviews before buying books, instead basing my decisions off of the summary. It's ridiculous to me that authors would pay for fake, generic reviews.

Speaking of reviews, I actually got an email from Amazon the other day saying my review of WANTED: DEAD OR UNDEAD helped another customer decide to purchase the book. ;)

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    NEWSLETTER

    Now Available!
    It's HERE! Get your copy today!

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    My Books

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Click for more info about Mallory Rock, Cover Designer
    Picture
    Click for more info about Megan Harris, Editor
    POPULAR BLOG POSTS

    Write under a pen name? What are you hiding from?

    The Jekyll and Hyde Aspect of Editing

    What kinds of WEIRD stuff have you researched for your WIP?

    Wow. Some book reviewers can be NASTY! Check it out

    Do you view other writers as friends or foes? (Conquering the green-eyed monster)

    3 reasons most writers give up & 3 reasons why YOU shouldn't

    My Twitter Pet Peeves

    How can I promote my book without ticking off the masses?

    10 Ways to promote your book and get surefire results!

    FUN LINKS
    ZOMG SO COOL


    DUDE I WANT THAT

    ALL THINGS ZOMBIE

    ZOMBIE CHRISTMAS

    Fun Stuff

    Picture
    Pixel of Ink
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    If you're ready for a zombie apocalypse, then you're ready for any emergency. emergency.cdc.gov
    Picture

    My BLOG Awards 

Photos used under Creative Commons from Jonathan Rolande, Leslie Richards, Su--May, mugwumpian, Say_No_To_Turtles, pedrosimoes7, tiannaspicer, comedy_nose, Lord Jim, corcell_usa, keepitsurreal, Dushan and Miae, Martin Pettitt, Chill Mimi, THX0477, Svenstorm, Grzegorz Łobiński, tsakshaug, Richard Elzey, epSos.de, ▓▒░ TORLEY ░▒▓, Asim Bijarani, Eddie~S, paul-simpson.org, ilovememphis, Sweet Dreamz Design, HockeyholicAZ
  • Home
  • About Me